
In my introductory list of topics I'm interested in, I (or, rather, Serge) didn't mention overwrought teen fiction about vampires and werewolves. That would be because I read the first three
Twilight books in spite of themselves. I can't explain it. They aren't well thought out, well paced, or well written. There are actual typos. Bella bothers me. Yet, I read the first three in three days and I know I'll read the fourth one on the plane to Japan. Why? I don't know why. But I will read it and I will see these movies, including the latest,
New Moon. Maybe this means I believe that passionate love exists out there, but I hope if I find it that it isn't as weirdly obsessive and one-dimensional as Bella and Edward's.
So as not to make this review as long, rambling, and self-conscious as one of Bella's interminable internal monologues doubting that Edward loves her, I'll organize it into the five points I'd like to make about the movie:
1. If you have a passing thought of seeing this movie but think you should read the books first, don't bother. It's really fine. Just see the movie. You aren't missing much. See
Twilight then see
New Moon and you'll be set when
Eclipse hits soon enough.
2. Taylor Lautner is painfully bad. Whitney and I couldn't stop laughing when he was on the screen. Jacob manages to pull Bella out of her depression, but director Chris Weitz and Kristen Stewart combined can't pull a decent performance out of this poor kid. He should have spent the time he wasn't using to add
30 pounds of muscle to take an acting class. As long as it didn't interfere with the workouts. He is 17. I am officially a creeper. In my defense, I had a lot of time to gather data about this since he doesn't wear a shirt for the second half of the movie.
3. Kristen Stewart somehow looks a lot more attractive this time around, even with all the scowling and self-flagellation. See this movie and tell me if you can you imagine Kristen Stewart doing comedy. I fear she might be a one-trick pony. One that frowns.
4. Question: Why does Bella believe Edward when he tells her that he doesn't want her? Either Edward or Robert Pattinson isn't a good actor (well, possibly both) and doesn't sell that line of reasoning for the Cullens' departure a bit. Answer: Because Bella has no sense of who she is or self-confidence or ANYTHING outside of Edward and her obsessive love for him. I know this. Yet, I am transfixed. Help me. He
smolders.
5. The soundtrack is awesome. I don't think it works as well as the
Where the Wild Things Are soundtrack, but it's excellent. Muse, Death Cab, Thom Yorke, Grizzly Bear, and Lykke Li (who my friends with much more pretentious taste in music than mine adore) all make an appearance. I am puzzled because the movie is aimed mainstream teenage girls and I can't imagine mainstream teenage girls listening to Bon Iver and St. Vincent. I hope I'm wrong.
I am kind of embarrassed to recommend that you go see this movie, but I really enjoyed it. Despite itself. The smaller roles, like Alice, Charlie, Jasper (although what is up with Jasper's
hair?), Carlisle, Jessica, and Emmet are often quite funny, if underutilized. Learning about the vampire world and werewolf world interests me (although, the books are much better for that, truth be told). I will continue to want to see these movies, even though I am totally aware that they are inherently problematic. Cognitive dissonance.